Stephen A. Smith Clowns Shannon Sharpe: How a Hall of Famer Became the Biggest Fumble in Sports Media

When you think of Shannon Sharpe, you think of the NFL Hall of Famer who turned his on-field charisma into one of the most entertaining media personalities in sports. For years, he was the guy who walked into any studio and immediately lit up the room — the uncle figure, the truth-teller, the cultural translator who could swing from serious to hilarious in a matter of seconds. But in 2025, Sharpe’s empire has come crashing down, and the collapse has been so public, so messy, and so humiliating that even his closest ally, Stephen A. Smith, couldn’t resist clowning him on live television.

And here’s the kicker: this wasn’t just banter between colleagues. Stephen A’s sarcasm, his sly remarks, and his refusal to cover for Shannon exposed a deeper reality — that Shannon’s career in sports media might already be finished. What we’re watching isn’t just the downfall of a man; it’s the unraveling of a legacy.

From King of Sports Media to Corporate Pariah

Only a year ago, Shannon Sharpe looked untouchable. After landing his explosive Club Shay Shay interview with comedian Katt Williams — an interview that blew up YouTube and racked up millions of views — Sharpe’s podcast became the most talked-about platform in sports media. Front Office Sports even reported in April 2025 that Sharpe was on the verge of signing a record-breaking $100 million deal for his podcast. Combined with his lucrative ESPN role on First Take and endorsement deals, he wasn’t just winning; he was dominating.

But the higher you climb, the further you fall.

By the summer, Sharpe found himself embroiled in a scandal involving OnlyFans model Gabrielle Zuniga, known online as “Carly.” Zuniga filed a $50 million lawsuit against Sharpe, alleging disturbing behavior and inappropriate encounters. At first, Shannon came out swinging. He called the lawsuit a “shakedown,” accused Zuniga’s lawyer Tony Buzbee of targeting Black men, and promised to countersue for defamation. He even released a fiery statement declaring he would “never give her a dime.”

But then the leaks started.

Disturbing audio recordings surfaced online, allegedly featuring Shannon making threats toward Zuniga. The clips went viral, and almost overnight, the tide shifted. What had been dismissed as opportunism by an internet model suddenly began to look like a damning case. Sharpe’s defense crumbled, and within months, reports emerged that he had quietly settled the case out of court for a massive payout rumored to be close to the original $50 million demand.

And just like that, the man who once made $22 million across his entire NFL career had handed over nearly double that to a woman he claimed was setting him up.

Stephen A. Smith Smells Blood

If you thought Stephen A. Smith — Shannon’s First Take cohost and supposed friend — would have his back, think again. Smith made it clear that while he personally didn’t believe Shannon was guilty of assault, he wasn’t about to defend Sharpe blindly. In fact, Smith’s tone was anything but sympathetic.

On air, he blasted Shannon for his “reckless proclivities,” boasting that you’d never catch him messing around with women 30 years his junior. He framed ESPN and Disney’s decision to distance themselves from Shannon as inevitable, practically gloating as he explained why the company couldn’t afford to be associated with him.

The sarcasm cut deep.

“You might be one of the dumbest folks on the planet Earth,” Smith quipped in one resurfaced clip, clowning Shannon as a man who had everything — wealth, fame, a platform — and threw it all away chasing distractions.

Fans watching the broadcast weren’t just shocked at Smith’s words; they were stunned by the venom behind them. Was Smith just being brutally honest? Or was this something more — a corporate hit job, a calculated takedown, maybe even a bit of jealousy? After all, Sharpe’s Club Shay Shay had been overshadowing ESPN’s traditional programming. Some fans wondered if Smith saw Shannon not as a partner, but as a threat.

The Fallout: From ESPN Darling to Dead Weight

For ESPN and Disney, the scandal was too much. Once the settlement was finalized, insiders say the company had no choice but to quietly sever ties. Sharpe received the dreaded “sack letter” via email. No press release, no farewell montage, no flowery send-off — just an unceremonious goodbye.

For a man whose ESPN salary had been the cornerstone of his media career, the firing was devastating. But it wasn’t just about money. It was about credibility. Losing First Take didn’t just mean losing a paycheck; it meant losing the last shred of mainstream respectability.

Meanwhile, the fallout spread elsewhere. Sponsors pulled back from Club Shay Shay. Merch lines were delayed. YouTube numbers cratered after the Katt Williams high, with every new episode compared unfavorably to that viral peak. Fans who once loved Shannon’s authenticity now dismissed him as a creep who ignored every warning sign.

And the evidence was right there in the archives. Old clips of comedian Mo’Nique warning him against dating women young enough to be his daughters resurfaced. Katt Williams himself bluntly told Shannon that no amount of fame could protect him if he didn’t wise up. Looking back, those moments felt prophetic, like omens Sharpe refused to heed.

The Money Pit

The lawsuits didn’t stop with Gabrielle Zuniga. Sharpe’s ex, Michelle Evans, re-entered the picture with her own $16 million defamation suit, reportedly armed with receipts that could bury him. Legal fees piled up. Settlement figures ballooned. Insiders whispered that Sharpe had gone from multimillionaire to cash-strapped almost overnight, forced to sell off pieces of his real estate portfolio — including his once-prized Atlanta property.

On TikTok, one viral commentator put it bluntly: “Gabby just collected Shannon’s entire football career earnings in one lawsuit. He played 14 seasons in the NFL, made $22 million total, and she got $23 million in a few months. That’s his whole career, gone.”

It was hard to argue with the math.

Fans Turn, Stephen A. Laughs

If Sharpe expected the public to rally to his defense, he miscalculated. Instead, fans flooded his comments with brutal reminders.

“Shannon, this could have all been avoided if you listened to Cat and Mo’Nique,” one wrote.

“Bro, take accountability. Look at the man in the mirror,” another chimed in.

When Sharpe finally addressed the situation in a somber “Nightcap” video, asking for sympathy and apologizing to his brother for “upstaging” him during his Hall of Fame weekend, the response was overwhelmingly negative. To fans, it felt like deflection — an attempt to sidestep accountability rather than own up to the choices that led to his downfall.

And then came Stephen A. again, pouring salt on the wound. After Shannon’s video went viral, Smith went live on his own channel to laugh at his former colleague, mocking his fall from grace. To many, this was the ultimate betrayal — the proof that whatever friendship had once existed between the two men was dead.

Smith even unfollowed Shannon on Instagram, a digital move that the internet quickly interpreted as a final nail in the coffin.

From OG to Punchline

At his peak, Shannon Sharpe was respected. He was the voice of reason, the culture’s uncle, the guy who could sit across from Skip Bayless or Stephen A. Smith and more than hold his own. He told it straight, unafraid to speak truth to power.

Now, he’s a cautionary tale.

The man who once ruled sports media is now broke, disgraced, unemployed, and abandoned by the very people who once hyped him up. His podcast is limping. His brand is toxic. And his reputation? Gone.

Meanwhile, Stephen A. Smith is still standing tall, still talking, still dominating.

Which raises the haunting question: did Stephen A. bury Shannon? Or did Shannon bury himself?

The truth is probably somewhere in the middle. Stephen A. didn’t need to sabotage Shannon — Sharpe did that all on his own. Smith just made sure to twist the knife once the damage was done.

The Biggest Fumble in Sports Media History

In the end, Shannon Sharpe’s story isn’t about bad luck or a single scandal. It’s about a pattern of reckless decisions, ignored warnings, and a refusal to take accountability until it was too late.

He had it all: the money, the platform, the respect. And he lost it all chasing validation, clout, and distractions.

As one YouTube commenter perfectly summed it up:

“This may be the biggest fumble in sports media history.”

And the worst part? They’re not wrong.

Full video: