Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively’s Hollywood Meltdown: How Deadpool, Petty Jokes, and a $400 Million Lawsuit Shattered Their Carefully Built Image

When Blake Lively signed on to co-star in It Ends With Us, the Colleen Hoover adaptation that promised to be one of 2024’s biggest films, few could have predicted it would spiral into one of Hollywood’s ugliest public feuds. What began as whispers of tension on set between Lively and director Justin Baldoni has now exploded into an all-out war of lawsuits, reputation damage, and bizarre pop culture crossovers—dragging her husband, Ryan Reynolds, into the fire. At the heart of it all: a $400 million lawsuit and allegations that Reynolds weaponized Deadpool itself to humiliate Baldoni.

This saga has become less about one movie and more about the toxic cocktail of ego, image management, and celebrity power struggles that Hollywood thrives on.

From Dream Project to War Zone

It Ends With Us was supposed to be Justin Baldoni’s crowning achievement. He had championed the Colleen Hoover bestseller for years, securing the rights, attaching himself as director, and building a production designed to elevate his reputation as a serious Hollywood storyteller. With Blake Lively onboard as both lead actress and producer, the film looked poised for cultural dominance.

But almost immediately, tensions surfaced. Insiders noticed a lack of camaraderie between Lively and Baldoni. They stopped following each other on social media, skipped joint press appearances, and avoided posing together during junkets. Fans were quick to note the awkwardness. Something was deeply off.

Behind the scenes, Lively reportedly grew frustrated with Baldoni’s directing style and his handling of female cast and crew. Allegations soon emerged accusing Baldoni of being overly controlling, insensitive, and even harassing. What might have been a contained HR nightmare instead spilled into the open.

The Image Problem

At first, Blake Lively positioned herself as the champion of women on set, the supportive producer standing up to “toxic behavior.” It played into her long-cultivated public image: stylish, intelligent, empowering, the ultimate girl-next-door who just happens to run Hollywood red carpets.

But then came the cracks. Old clips resurfaced showing Lively being dismissive or rude toward crew members. Social media pounced. Memes flew. Her “America’s sweetheart” aura suddenly looked like a carefully polished façade.

Fans started asking: was Lively truly protecting others, or just protecting her own brand? The narrative began shifting. And then Ryan Reynolds entered the battlefield.

Ryan Reynolds and the “Nice Pool” Disaster

Reynolds, never one to resist a joke, may have delivered the deadliest blow to his wife’s case without even realizing it. In Deadpool 2, he introduced a character named “Nice Pool”—a parody of toxic masculinity. The character was snarky, condescending, and dismissive of feminism, eerily echoing some of the very allegations levied against Justin Baldoni.

At first glance, this was standard Reynolds humor—over-the-top satire that skewers real-world stereotypes. But Baldoni’s legal team saw something much more sinister: a calculated mockery of the accusations against their client.

Baldoni’s lawyers argue that Reynolds deliberately crafted “Nice Pool” as a caricature of Baldoni himself—using the global platform of Deadpool to reduce serious harassment allegations into a punchline. The character’s hairstyle, sarcastic feminist jokes, even comments about women’s bodies all seemed to mirror Baldoni’s alleged behavior on the It Ends With Us set.

What may have been a throwaway gag suddenly became Exhibit A in a massive lawsuit.

The $400 Million Legal Bomb

By January 2025, Baldoni had escalated the conflict into a lawsuit seeking more than $400 million in damages from Blake Lively, Ryan Reynolds, and their PR representative Sloan. The claims: defamation, extortion, and intentional destruction of his career.

According to court documents, Baldoni alleges that Lively and Reynolds orchestrated a smear campaign against him—leaking damaging information, manipulating Hollywood’s gossip cycle, and using their celebrity clout to poison his reputation. He claims they blackmailed him into silence and then mocked him publicly through Deadpool.

And then came another explosive accusation: fat shaming.

Lively alleges that Baldoni humiliated her before filming by inquiring about her weight in preparation for a lifting scene—insensitive, she argued, given that she had just given birth to her fourth child. Baldoni countered that his concern was medical, linked to chronic back issues. What Lively viewed as harassment, Baldoni insists was practicality.

To make matters worse, Lively claims that during a kissing scene, Baldoni prolonged the moment unnecessarily, making her uncomfortable.

Whether these incidents rise to the level of harassment is now the subject of heated legal arguments—but what’s clear is that Baldoni has no intention of going down quietly.

PR Warfare: The Battle for Hollywood Sympathy

Blake Lively’s PR team has scrambled to keep her image intact. At first, they painted her as the victim, the brave woman standing up in a male-dominated industry. But as more evidence and contradictory stories surfaced, the strategy shifted. Carefully timed press releases, sympathetic interviews, and selective leaks tried to reframe the narrative.

The problem? Ryan Reynolds.

While Lively’s camp framed her as a voice of empowerment, Reynolds’s Deadpool satire undercut the seriousness of the allegations. Baldoni’s legal team seized on the contradiction: how could Lively claim moral high ground while her husband was turning the accusations into a joke?

To critics, it looked less like a noble stand and more like Hollywood power players using mockery to bury a rival.

Hollywood Turns

As the lawsuits flew, so did the court of public opinion. Instagram unfollows piled up. Fans began questioning whether they could still adore the Lively-Reynolds duo, once hailed as Hollywood’s golden couple.

Some defended Blake, arguing Baldoni was a thin-skinned director who couldn’t handle criticism. Others sided with Baldoni, painting Blake and Ryan as manipulative bullies leveraging their A-list status.

Insiders whispered that this was more than a feud—it was a potential career-ender. If Baldoni could prove even part of his $400 million claim, the financial and reputational damage to Blake and Ryan could be devastating.

Deadpool’s Joke Becomes a Liability

The irony is staggering. Reynolds’s Deadpool character, famous for breaking the fourth wall and satirizing real-life absurdities, may now be the very thing breaking his wife’s legal defense.

What was once comedy is now evidence. Baldoni’s lawyers argue that Reynolds’s parody blurred the line between fiction and reality, trivializing serious allegations and undermining the credibility of the women involved.

In Hollywood, satire is currency—but when it collides with real-life lawsuits, it can quickly turn toxic. For Lively, the satire has transformed from a cute marital in-joke into a weapon aimed squarely at her credibility.

The Bigger Picture: Hollywood, Power, and Petty Revenge

Strip away the star power, and this saga is a cautionary tale about how fragile reputations are in Hollywood. Lively carefully cultivated her image for years, but one scandal exposed how quickly the public can turn. Reynolds, the master of satire, may have finally discovered a joke that backfired.

Baldoni, once a rising Hollywood darling, is now staking his future on a courtroom showdown, claiming he was destroyed by the very people he trusted.

And It Ends With Us, the film that sparked it all? It may go down less as a cultural milestone and more as Hollywood’s most infamous cautionary tale about ego, image, and the dangers of turning real-life scandals into punchlines.

Conclusion: Who Actually Wins?

As the case grinds on, one truth is undeniable: nobody looks good.

Blake Lively’s carefully crafted image has cracked. Ryan Reynolds’s comedic genius is now weaponized against him. Justin Baldoni’s career hangs by a thread, tied to a lawsuit that could either vindicate him or finish him off entirely.

This is no longer about one movie. It’s about what happens when Hollywood’s obsession with control, image, and satire collides with the very real stakes of power and misconduct.

And if there’s one lesson to be learned, it’s this: sometimes, the joke doesn’t just fall flat. Sometimes, it blows up your whole career.

Full video: