The Secret Feuds of Aretha Franklin: The Queen of Soul’s Silent Wars with Dionne Warwick, Patti LaBelle, and Diana Ross

In music, some artists become stars overnight. Others become legends—forces of nature who don’t chase stardom, but define it. Aretha Franklin never had to maintain her glow. She was the glow, the Queen of Soul, a title earned through grit, pain, gospel, and an incomparable voice. Yet the higher one ascends, the more adversaries emerge, whether real or perceived. Behind the applause, behind the thunderous chords and shattering vocals, Franklin carried a hidden gallery of grudges—silent wars against peers who, for one reason or another, stood too close to her throne.

Not many dared to say it aloud, but at least six figures in American music history once caused Franklin to turn cold, distant, even unforgiving. Among them were three of the most iconic women in Black music: Dionne Warwick, Patti LaBelle, and Diana Ross. Their stories, shrouded in silence, rivalry, and quiet disdain, reveal a deeper truth about the world of Black female artists: a stage too small for more than one queen at a time.

Dionne Warwick: A Prayer Turned Cold

The first of Franklin’s long-standing feuds was with Dionne Warwick. On the surface, both women shared similarities—powerful Black female voices, chart-topping hits, and deep roots in gospel traditions. But Franklin always viewed Warwick with suspicion, perhaps even resentment.

It all came to a head in 2012, at Whitney Houston’s funeral. Warwick, attempting to honor Franklin, introduced her as Houston’s godmother. Franklin wasn’t even present—and she had never assumed that role. To most, it seemed like a minor slip, perhaps even an innocent fabrication. To Franklin, it was an unforgivable offense.

“She blatantly lied on me,” Franklin later told reporters in 2017, still seething five years after the event. That statement wasn’t just a correction—it was a declaration of war. A coldness settled between the two women that would never thaw.

But the feud didn’t begin there. The tension dated back to the late 1960s when Franklin recorded I Say a Little Prayer, a song Warwick had already made famous. Franklin’s rendition, heavier with emotion, richer in arrangement, instantly overshadowed the original. For Warwick, it was her anthem. For Franklin, it was proof of dominance. She didn’t just sing it—she weaponized it, turning a love song into a subtle yet powerful reminder of who truly ruled the soul landscape.

In truth, Franklin may have seen Warwick as a reflection of what she despised about the industry’s treatment of Black women: the polished, lighter, more “acceptable” type of artist who appealed to white audiences. Warwick was pop-R&B, easy to consume. Franklin was raw gospel soul, a primal scream born of suppression and survival. In her mind, there was no comparison.

This wasn’t a feud of insults or public slaps. It was one of silence—an icy absence of photos, collaborations, or embraces. Two icons, two parallel lines, destined never to meet.

Patti LaBelle: A Cold War of Divas

If Warwick was a thorn in Franklin’s side, Patti LaBelle was a mirror—too similar, too powerful, too unwilling to stand in anyone else’s shadow. And Franklin had no intention of sharing a throne.

The most famous glimpse into their frosty relationship came in 2014, at the BET Awards. Cameras captured a moment lasting less than three seconds but dissected endlessly by fans. As Franklin walked past, LaBelle’s hand rose slightly, almost reaching out, then stopped midair. Franklin never looked at her. The clip went viral, sparking arguments online. Accident? Oversight? Or deliberate? Those who knew Franklin insisted the Queen of Soul never acted by accident.

Their rivalry had always been quiet but unmistakable. Industry whispers claimed Franklin once refused to appear on a show if LaBelle was also scheduled. No proof, just rumors—but enough to fuel the fire. Organizers often kept them apart, knowing the chill between them could freeze an entire room.

LaBelle once hinted at the truth in an interview: “Sometimes people don’t like sharing a stage.” For the discerning listener, it was less a statement and more a wound laid bare.

Both women had roots in gospel, both carried the weight of Black womanhood in America, and both had voices that could shake audiences to tears. But while Franklin embodied dignity, tradition, and regal control, LaBelle was fire—explosive, sensual, unapologetically flamboyant. They represented two sides of the same coin, two different visions of Black female artistry.

To fans, their distance became a cultural cold war. Franklin’s supporters viewed her as the monument of soul, the unshakable Queen. LaBelle’s fans celebrated her wild energy and stratospheric high notes. Neither side would admit the other was equal. And neither woman was willing to bend.

When Franklin passed in 2018, LaBelle paid her respects with a formal, proper statement. But the tone was enough to reveal the truth: this was not the farewell of a friend. Their story was never about hatred in the traditional sense—it was about survival in an industry that allowed no vulnerability, no shared crowns.

Diana Ross: The Queen and the Supreme

If Warwick was a rival, and LaBelle a mirror, Diana Ross was something altogether more dangerous: a cultural archetype that made Franklin deeply uncomfortable.

Ross, the face of Motown, was everything Franklin was not. She was polished, glamorous, meticulously packaged for mass consumption. While Franklin was the raw soul forged in Detroit’s Black churches, Ross was the Hollywood-ready star, dazzling in gowns, choreographed to perfection, embraced by white mainstream America.

The media fed on their differences. In the 1970s and 80s, magazines and newspapers—Jet, Ebony, Rolling Stone—posed the same question again and again: Who is the real queen? It was an unfair framing, but one that drove a wedge. Franklin knew she was the Queen of Soul, a title earned in sweat and gospel fire. But Ross was “Supreme,” bolstered by the Motown machine, film roles, and Oscar nominations.

Organizers of charity events quietly admitted Franklin often refused to appear if Ross was scheduled. At Motown anniversary celebrations, she declined invitations. When the two did appear in the same room, Franklin would refuse to sit at the same table. Their absence from each other’s careers was glaring: in decades of overlapping dominance, they never recorded together.

Ross, ever the diplomat, never said a bad word about Franklin. But Franklin didn’t need Ross to wrong her—the mere fact that Ross was favored by the establishment was insult enough. In a world where Franklin fought for respect as a raw, authentic soul singer, Ross was rewarded for embodying what America wanted from its Black stars: glamour, polish, and entertainment over pain.

For Franklin, Ross was less a rival than a reminder: that the system itself could crown a “queen” regardless of authenticity.

The Cost of Queenship

Aretha Franklin’s grudges weren’t petty squabbles. They were born from a lifetime of survival in an industry that demanded perfection from Black women, then rewarded only a select few. Each feud—Warwick, LaBelle, Ross—revealed a different facet of that struggle:

With Warwick, Franklin refused to let her own legacy be misrepresented, even by accident.

With LaBelle, she refused to share a throne in a world that barely allowed room for one Black diva.

With Ross, she refused to accept an industry that measured Black artistry by glamour rather than grit.

To the outside world, these were cold silences, icy glances, avoided stages. To Franklin, they were acts of self-preservation. She had fought too hard, endured too much, to let anyone diminish the space she had carved.

In the end, Franklin’s grudges were as much about the industry as the individuals. Each feud wasn’t just personal—it was symbolic, a reflection of the painful truth that in American music, the stage for Black women was never wide enough.

When Franklin passed in 2018, tributes poured in from every corner of the globe. Her voice had been the soundtrack of survival, her songs hymns of respect and self-assertion. Yet behind that towering legacy lay a darker, quieter truth: the Queen of Soul carried grudges as sharp as her high notes, as enduring as her reign.

Because to be queen was not just to sing. It was to defend a throne, even if it meant turning her back—silently, coldly, forever—on those who dared to stand too close.

Full video: