Blake Lively: From Golden Girl to “Mean Girl”? America Ferrera Spills Tea on Shocking Set Behavior

Blake Lively’s seemingly flawless public persona is taking a hit—or at least, her former co-star America Ferrera says it should. Known for her glamorous roles and effortless charm on-screen, Blake has long been considered Hollywood’s “golden girl,” the perfect mix of beauty, charm, and wit. But digging into Hollywood history, especially her early career on Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants, a different picture emerges. According to Ferrera, Blake Lively was anything but kind.

It all starts back in 2005, when Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants hit theaters. Ferrera and Lively co-starred in the beloved film, which has since become a cultural touchstone for young women navigating friendship, love, and self-discovery. On-screen, the duo seemed like the perfect pair, but behind the cameras, tensions were allegedly high. America Ferrera recently resurfaced old claims suggesting that Blake’s behavior on set was not just bossy but cruel, with Ferrera bearing the brunt of her co-star’s alleged mean-spirited jokes.

According to insiders, Blake allegedly made fun of Ferrera’s weight and physical appearance repeatedly. Even when Ferrera expressed discomfort, Blake reportedly doubled down, gaslighting her into thinking she was overreacting. The story paints a picture of a young actress establishing dominance on set by targeting a fellow cast member, creating a toxic dynamic that affected Ferrera’s ability to work comfortably.

Ferrera isn’t the only one who has allegedly felt Blake’s wrath. Reports suggest that the Gossip Girl star used similar tactics with Penn Badgley during their time on the show. Penn, who played her love interest, was allegedly sabotaged from day one, with Blake reportedly spreading rumors to turn other cast members against him. For no apparent reason other than personal dislike, Blake seemed to engineer a hostile environment, reinforcing her status as the set’s golden girl while isolating those she didn’t favor.

The pattern continues with Justin Baldoni during the production of It Ends With Us. Fans and insiders noticed that Lively and the other cast members treated Justin strangely, as if he weren’t part of the team. Separate press tours, solo appearances, and even alleged interference with the movie script pointed to what some are calling a deliberate campaign to undermine Baldoni. Reports suggest that Blake used Ryan Reynolds’ influence to make executive decisions, further consolidating control over the set and leaving Justin in the shadows.

This type of behavior reportedly mirrors earlier incidents, including tensions with co-stars like Leighton Meester. Although Blake and Leighton appeared close on-screen as Serena and Blair, behind the scenes, their personalities clashed. Interviews and insider accounts suggest that Blake went out of her way to be insensitive, making jokes about Leighton being born in a prison cell or comparing co-stars to monkeys on live television. While some of these remarks were framed as humor, sources say they reflected deeper, more harmful tension that other cast members felt compelled to navigate carefully.

Interestingly, these alleged patterns extend beyond co-stars. Blake’s approach to press events and interviews has often been described as “tone-deaf” or inconsiderate. During promotions for It Ends With Us, a film about domestic violence, Blake reportedly prioritized her own branding—launching a hair care line and an alcoholic beverage—even as the movie’s themes demanded a more sensitive approach. Interviews during this time occasionally came off as awkward, with Blake displaying an odd blend of pettiness and defensiveness, reinforcing her reputation as difficult to work with.

Another example involves Anna Kendrick during the 2018 thriller A Simple Favor. Tension reportedly arose from Anna making jokes about Blake’s best friend Taylor Swift. Blake allegedly took the comments personally and responded by attempting to sabotage the production, creating further on-set drama that affected other cast members. Over time, the tension escalated, ultimately resulting in the actresses distancing themselves professionally. In one interview, Anna even admitted to muting Blake across social media platforms to avoid interaction, underscoring the severity of the rift.

Perhaps the most ironic aspect of all this is Blake Lively’s recent legal claims against Justin Baldoni. According to reports, Blake alleges that Justin fat-shamed her by trying to access her weight through her personal trainer. Justin’s response counters this narrative, stating that any inquiry about Blake’s weight was strictly professional, tied to a scene requiring him to carry her due to back issues. The striking parallel is that Blake herself allegedly engaged in similar behavior toward Ferrera years ago—mocking a co-star’s body under the guise of humor. The hypocrisy has not gone unnoticed by fans, who find it ironic that the “golden girl” now faces accusations reminiscent of her past conduct.

Even more revealing is the dynamic of loyalty and influence that seems to follow Blake. According to sources, when she had issues with a co-star, she didn’t stop at personal grievances. She allegedly recruited other cast members to join her side, amplifying the pressure on her target. This was seen with both Penn Badgley and America Ferrera, where cast members felt compelled to participate in the social ostracization or manipulation simply to avoid conflict with Blake. The result was an environment where dissent was stifled, and the perceived “golden girl” maintained control both on and off-screen.

Fans have also noted a striking continuity in Blake’s behavior across decades. From Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants to Gossip Girl to her more recent film projects, reports consistently describe her as commanding, manipulative, and occasionally cruel. Whether targeting co-stars or handling press, Blake’s approach often blurs the line between assertiveness and toxicity. Even in situations framed as professional disputes, her behavior reportedly extends into personal attacks, leaving behind a trail of frustrated co-stars and tense on-set environments.

Of course, not everyone agrees with this depiction. Some co-stars have publicly expressed support for Blake, and she maintains a devoted fan base that sees her as charming, witty, and highly professional. However, the repeated claims across multiple productions—from Ferrera to Badgley, Meester, Kendrick, and Baldoni—suggest that there may be a pattern that’s worth examining.

What makes these revelations particularly compelling is the intersection of Blake’s public image and her private conduct. In media appearances, she projects warmth, humor, and relatability, yet behind the scenes, multiple accounts suggest a more calculating and, at times, cruel persona. This duality raises questions about celebrity culture and the way media often shields stars from accountability while fans are encouraged to celebrate their curated image.

For Ferrera, revisiting these claims decades later is a powerful reminder of what she allegedly endured. It also offers context for how Hollywood dynamics can affect actors long after the cameras stop rolling. Ferrera, along with other actresses from the Sisterhood cast, issued statements supporting Blake during her legal battles, highlighting the complexity of relationships forged in Hollywood: admiration, fear, loyalty, and resentment can coexist in the same space, creating a tangled web of professional and personal stakes.

Ultimately, Blake Lively’s story—as seen through these allegations—is a cautionary tale about power, influence, and accountability in Hollywood. The juxtaposition of her public charm with alleged behind-the-scenes cruelty underscores the challenges actors face in navigating both celebrity culture and interpersonal dynamics on set. While Blake’s talent and career achievements are undeniable, these revelations invite audiences to reconsider the price of maintaining the “golden girl” image and whether charm and public appeal can mask deeper patterns of behavior.

The irony of Blake’s alleged past behavior comes full circle in her legal battles and current press attention. What once might have been brushed off as harmless jokes or playful competition now takes on a new meaning under the lens of professional accountability. Fans and co-stars alike are asking whether the world should reconcile the public image with the private behavior, and whether the golden girl persona is as polished as it seems.

As the drama continues to unfold—from Ferrera’s revelations to Justin Baldoni’s legal disputes—the larger conversation around celebrity behavior and accountability in Hollywood gains momentum. Blake Lively, once celebrated as the epitome of charm and grace, now faces scrutiny not just for isolated incidents, but for a decades-long pattern of behavior alleged by multiple co-stars. Whether one views her actions as misunderstood assertiveness or as a genuine “mean girl” streak, the narrative is forcing Hollywood and its fans to grapple with the duality of fame: the shine of the spotlight versus the shadows behind the cameras.

In the end, the story of Blake Lively is more than gossip—it’s a lens into the complexities of power, gender dynamics, and personal behavior in the entertainment industry. From Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants to modern-day legal battles, the lines between charm and cruelty, professionalism and manipulation, are often blurred. And as more voices come forward, one thing becomes clear: Hollywood’s golden girl is far more complicated than anyone imagined.

Full video: